Hi! I'm Lindsay Ferrier. You might remember me from a blog called Suburban Turmoil. Well, a lot has changed since I started that blog in 2005. My kids grew up, I got a divorce, and I finally left the suburbs for the heart of Nashville, where I feel like I truly belong. I have no idea what the future will hold and you know what? I'm okay with that. Thrilled, actually. It was time for something totally different.
March 21, 2006
>When Lucinda asked me to guest post while she hits the slopes somewhere fabulous, I accepted without giving it another thought. What an honor to be blogging in the stead of the great Lucinda! Hell, she knows Busy Mom.
Besides, if I can take just one iota of credit for one blogger’s future knee replacement, I know I’ll have done a great public service for the needy orthopedists of the world.
My initial idea was to lend an urban counterpoint to the notion of suburban turmoil. So I scribbled a few notes about coat closets as a commodity, the Upper East Side Bugaboo brigades, and the distinctive smell of urine boiling in the subways that heralds the coming of summer.
I thought about the toothless A-train panhandlers with Vietnam flak jackets and stumps for legs who just break your heart no matter how many times you see them. I considered the drivers who, once within city limits, lose their ability to perceive the dotted lines that divide the lanes. I examined the cost of living here, which is code for, “hm, should I garage my car or feed my family for a month?” And I touched a bit on the agonizing preschool acceptance process which is on par with the lesser known co-op acceptance process—imagine submitting your last ten tax returns and fourteen letters of recommendation, going on three separate interviews, shelling out monthly fees almost equal to your mortgage payments, and still ending up with neighbors whose dogs crap in the hallways.
But just as my urban turmoil list was getting somewhere interesting, I received a surprise visit from the fiercely proud New Yorker within, that alter ego who comes bearing a counterpoint to my own counterpoint. Also some rugelach from that little bakery on Second.
The truth? I love living in the city. Lllllove it. Five L’s worth.
New York moms wear their manic lifestyles like a badge of honor and I’m no exception. The energy, the chaos the cacophony–it fuels and inspires me and I’m hard-pressed to give it up.
Lest you think I’m selfish depriving my daughter of, I don’t know, a lawn–that’s what grandma’s house is for. Here in the city, my daughter is going to grow up experiencing something entirely new every day: a new plant at the green market, a new mural on a gas station wall, a new crazy person with a flowerpot on his head doing a hula dance for quarters.
She is going to take for granted that there are fifty things to do on a rainy Sunday besides go to the mall. She is going to consider it odd that some towns have people with faces all the same color. She is never going to think twice about children who have two mommies or older mommies or mommies who never had a partner at all.
And most importantly, she will dress impeccably.
Am I justifying? No! (yes) Not at all! (a little) Let’s face it, there’s no perfect answer as to where our children should be raised. Every place is right and every place is wrong. But given my choice between the plastic people and the crazy people, I’ll take the crazy people.
For now.
I reserve the right to go plastic any time. There’s a lot to be said for lawns.
To read more from Mom 101, check out her blog here.
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
>*sigh* I miss the city. The culture (naked cowboy), the food (hotdogs… Thanks for the memories…
>This is EXCELLENT. I live in a different sort of urban jungle–jungle lite, DC–but I love NYC and I think you are right on to raise your daughter there. Really, what are we protecting them from when we put them in homogeneous bacteria free space modules? (aka “garden communities”)Not sure.I think we’re protecting them from seeing life as it is, and NYC certainly shows you life in all its incarnations, whether you want it to or not.
>a) you have made me jealous that i do not live in a big city any more (lived in london for a time, and did i miss a lawn–NO).b) made me realize that tho’ i have a lawn now, my son could not give a rat’s ass about it. said lawn is also bane of my existence because it dies midsummer. (and turns to mud/pervasive dust).c) i live in a downtown urban renewal area in lansing, michigan–and it’s the place to be to meet non-plastic people who will get drunk with you on weekends, and co-share babysitters. works for me.
>This is a question my husband and I ponder EVERY time we move. It is our dream to live in a city. Yet each time we move the lawn thing takes over and we think about the kids who’s feet rarely touch the grass yet here we are, the schools we could NEVER afford in the city because there are 4 of them, and the being close to his job so that he actually spends more time with them as opposed to the bumper to bumper traffic. My kids have spring break next week and we will spend it driving into the city (Chicago 30minute drive) to hit the free days at all of the museums. maybe even the free Lincoln Park Zoo -weather permitting. I LOVE THE CITYWe have made an oath that when the kids are gone we will live in the city! unless there are a lot of grandkids….p.s. I hope you make her quota
>crazy people is good
>Man you make me miss that city, but my boys would piss off A LOT of neighbors playing hockey in the hallways!
>cute post! i’m so glad lucinda got you to guest post, so now i can go check you out at home.
>your daughter will love the city because you do. not one place is perfect, you’re right.i think we should live where we feel good. want a little nature? go camping. want some room to play outside? go to a park. hell, at least she’ll grow up not being phased by “real life” like traffic or the crazies! that’s a plus!
>This might just be my favorite post from you.
>I’m just jealous that you can get rugelach. I don’t even live in the ‘burbs and good rugelach is going the way of the milkman and full service gas stations…which is to say it hardly exists here. I’d live in NYC in half a heartbeat but selling my overpriced tiny little house in Florida might buy me an overpriced little coat closet in NY. (I keep meaning to mention to you that my biological mom lives in Brooklyn and my half brother lives somewhere around Chelsea)
>When I visit friends and their green lawns, sprawling new houses and minivans..I counter it by knowing how beautiful the city parks are, I don’t have to choke down chain restaurant food and of course, I can walk to the nearest bar..you can’t do that in surburbia!
>I do believe I’m choking back the tears. Having grown up in NYC, I think there’s no better place for kids. I can’t believe my daughter is growing up in MAINE! I’m going to have to homeschool her in Remedial Moxie, Street Smarts and Sometimes People Aren’t White. Oy.
>I live in Toronto, so not nearly as big or cityish as NYC, but still a pretty great city. As a kid (kinda..sixteen years old) who’s lived in this city all her life, I’ve gotta say it hasn’t been half bad…in fact it’s been pretty great. I really agree with what you said about your daughter not thinking twice about people with different lifestyles, that’s one of the best parts of living in the city-interacting and being friends with people of different ethnicities and lifestyles 🙂
>I lived in the country growing up, and the suburbs for most of the rest of my life. There are times I do really wish that I could raise my family in the city proper, but fortunately my community is very diverse and we try to get into the city frequently to take advantage of the culture and amenities. And guess what — we don’t have a yard (and don’t miss it one bit!)
>What a wonderful ode to city living!!!